Property Divisions
Marriage Counseling as a
First Step
Any marriage that was
once good may be worth saving. It is important to
remember that we can't love our mates at all hours
of the day on all days of the week. Let's face it.
Marriages take work. Before you consider divorce,
reconsider your marriage. Divorce is and should be a
final and drastic step.
Click here to review links that may help
you save your marriage.
Grounds for
Divorce
Wisconsin, like most states, is a "no fault" divorce
state. That means that no grounds or "fault" is
necessary to file a divorce. In fact, under most
circumstances issues of fault such as infidelity are
irrelevant to the proceedings. The only legal basis
for divorce in Wisconsin is that the marriage is
“irretrievably broken.” Wisconsin courts generally
will find a marriage irretrievably broken even if
only one of the spouses wants a divorce.
Legal
Separation
If you do believe that your marriage relationship
may be salvaged or for religious reasons do not want
to proceed with divorce, you may still separate and
address financial issues through a legal separation.
Just like a divorce the court may divide property,
determine custody and physical placement, child
support, and maintenance. The only difference
between a legal separation and a divorce is that in
a divorce the marital relationship is severed. A
legal separation may also be converted into a
divorce by either party after one year.
Annulments
In our modern world, an annulment tends to be
more a creature of religion than of law. Annulments
are rarely granted and when they are, very specific
circumstances must exist. Often people believe that
they may annul a marriage simply because it was of a
very short duration. That is not the case. To annul
a marriage, a person must demonstrate that the
marriage is void because it is
prohibited by the laws of the State or is
voidable because the intent to enter into a
civil contract was not present at the time that the
parties married. When an annulment is granted, it
dissolves a marriage and treats it as if it had
never occurred. Some reasons for annulment include
bigamy, marriage under the age of consent, marriage
by force, marriage based on fraud, marriage without
disclosing sexual impotency.
Wisconsin
Jurisdiction
In order to file a divorce in
Wisconsin, you must demonstrate that Wisconsin has
jurisdiction. There is a residency requirement that
one spouse must have been lived in Wisconsin for at
least six months immediately prior to the divorce
filing. The divorce may be filed in any county where
one spouse has lived for at least 30 days.
Alternatives
to Court Battles
The way a divorce is commenced
and how long it takes may depend on the process that
you choose. Not all divorce issues must be resolved
in a court room battle. The simplest divorce is one
that is resolved by an agreement of the parties.
Once an agreement is reached, it can be taken to a
lawyer to draft up all the necessary divorce
papers. This process will obviously save each of
the parties significant time, money and emotional
turmoil. However, in most cases, the parties will
need help in reaching agreements. In such cases,
the parties may try mediation to resolve their
issues. Although mediation may occur before a
dissolution proceeding is commenced., where there
are unresolved issues, it is also likely to be
required by the Court after divorce papers are
filed. Click on the hyper link for information on
the benefits of the
Mediation Process.
Often, the divorce process turns
spouses into bitter adversaries requiring them to
argue and fight about issues. This is generally not
a pleasant process. It can be time consuming,
emotionally draining and expensive. For that
reason, an alternative has been developed which
provides each spouse with legal advice and treats
the parties to a divorce like team members allowing
them to discuss and resolve their issues in creative
ways. Often, this process leads to better, lasting
solutions, reduces costs and speed up the process.
Click on the link for more information on
Collaborative Law - Divorce Without War.
How To Start & How Long Does It Take
To commence a divorce in the
Court system, two documents must be filed with the
Clerk of Court in your county along with a filing
fee and served on the other party. The documents
include the following:
-
A Summons which indicates that a divorce is
being filed;
-
A Petition for Dissolution of Marriage which
sets out basic factual information about the
each spouse, the children, if any, and asset
information along with a request for relief
from the Court.
The
person filing the documents is referred to as the
“petitioner.” The other spouse is referred to as the
“respondent.” There are few advantages or
disadvantages to being the first one to file. The
only real advantage is being able to choose the
county where the action is filed if the parties live
in different counties.
Pursuant to Wisconsin statutes,
except for certain emergencies, a final hearing
cannot be held for a minimum of 120 days.
However, the divorce process may, in fact last much
longer depending on the complexities of the case.
Divorces are concluded mist rapidly when the parties
are able to agree upon the issues related to debt
and property division, child support, and spousal
maintenance.
Once the divorce is final, both parties must wait at
least six months before remarrying.
Temporary
Hearings
Since the divorce process may span many months,
either party may schedule a temporary hearing in
order to resolve urgent issues on a temporary basis
such as the issue of temporary custody, physical
placement, child support, spousal maintenance, and
payment of debt. Such temporary orders remain in
effect until the divorce is finalized. Temporary
orders may be reviewed during the process if there
is a change in circumstance. To commence a
temporary hearing the following documents must be
served and filed:
- An Affidavit for Temporary Relief sets out
the facts on which a party will rely to support
his or her request for relief. Relief requested
may include temporary arrangements for child
custody and placement, visitation, support,
maintenance, division of debt and assets or
spousal maintenance.
- An Order to Show Cause or a Motion for
Temporary Relief informs the other party of the
time and date of the hearing before the family
court commissioner who will establish the
temporary orders and compels that party's
appearance at the hearing.
A Family Court Commissioner will generally
preside at a temporary hearing. The Family Court
Commissioner is essentially an assistant judge
with the same broad authority of a Judge to make
orders in the divorce on a "temporary basis."
At a temporary hearing the Court Commissioner
will wish to see a completed financial
statement from each party. The financial
statement provides the commissioner with a
summary of each party's income, assets and
liabilities. You should also bring to the
hearing any information that is critical to the
issues in dispute.
Temporary orders are not supposed to have "precedential"
value at the final hearing. This means that a
temporary order should not be considered by the
Court when making a final ruling on the issues.
Unfortunately, that is not always the case in
practice. Often Judge's lean toward preserving
the status quo which means that a party that
receives a favorable temporary order may have
obtained a significant strategic advantage over
the other party at the time of the final
hearing. Any decision that is made by a family
court commissioner may be appealed to a Judge of
the circuit court. At the new hearing, the
Court must hear the issues "de novo." This means
that the issue is hear new without giving any
weight to the prior decision by the Court
Commissioner.
Child Custody:
Child custody is one of the most contentious
issues in a divorce proceeding. It is important to
remember that there are two kinds of custody
- Legal custody refers to the
right of the parents to participate in important
decisions in the lives of their child(ren). This
specifically includes decisions related to
schooling, medical care, religion,
extra-curricular activities and other important
events. There is a very strong presumption under
Wisconsin law that these responsibilities should
be shared by the parties. The only time that
legal custody is not shared is when the parties
demonstrate a complete inability to communicate
or where there has been domestic abuse.
- Physical Placement is what
most people think of when they hear the term
custody. It refers to the primary physical
residence where the child will live. What used
to be referred to as visitation with the other
parent, is now called "periods of temporary
placement". There is a presumption under
Wisconsin law that each party is entitled to the
maximum period of physical placement. This
means the mother and the father are equally
entitled to the custody of the child. However,
in making a determination regarding physical
placement, the court must determine what is in
the "best interest of the child." This
determination is made, in part, by considering
all facts relevant to the best interest of the
child including the following statutory factors:
- The wishes of the child's parent or
parents.
- The wishes of the child, which may be
communicated by the child or through the
child's guardian ad litem or other
appropriate professional;
- The interaction and interrelationship of
the child with his or her parent or parents,
siblings, and any other person who may
significantly affect the child's best
interest;
- The child's adjustment to the home,
school, religion and community;
- The mental and physical health of the
parties, the minor children and other
persons living in a proposed custodial
house-hold;
- The availability of public or private
child care services;
- Whether one party is likely to
unreasonably interfere with the child's
continuing relationship with the other
party;
- Whether there is evidence that a party
engaged in abuse, as defined in s. 813.122
(1) (a), of the child, as defined in s.
48.02 (2).
- Whether there is evidence of
interspousal battery as de-scribed under s.
940.19 or 940.20 (1m) or domestic abuse as
de-fined in s. 813.12 (1) (a).
- Whether either party has or had a
significant problem with alcohol or drug
abuse;
- Such other factors as the court may in
each individual case determine to be
relevant.
Where custody and placement disputes exist, the
parties may be ordered to participate in mediation.
If mediation fails, the Court appoints a Guardian Ad
Litem to represent the interest of the children and
to make recommendations related to custody and
physical placement. The Court may also require a
custody evaluation performed by court services.
Guardian Ad Litem & Custody Evaluations
If custody cannot be resolved in mediation, then
the court must proceed with a custody determination.
To facilitate the process and evaluate the
allegations of each of the parties, the court will
appointment a guardian ad litem to represent the
interests of the children. The Guardian Ad Litem
operates, to an extent, as a legal counsel for the
children and is charged with seeing to their best
interest in the legal proceeding. The Court may also
require a custody evaluation performed by the county
social service agency. As part of a
“Custody Evaluation” an
evaluator meets with the parties and evaluates the
custody issues based on the factors for determining
custody that are spelled out by Wisconsin Statutes.
Once the custody evaluation is complete the
evaluator submits a report to the Court which will
recommend a custody and visitation schedule that the
evaluator believes is in the child’s best interests.
This report is a critical element
of your case. Although custody studies may be
challenged in court, many Judge’s defer to the
recommendations of the evaluator because, unlike the
parties, they are deemed to be an independent
witness without any personal Interest in the
outcome. As a result how you relate your case to the
evaluator is very important.
To learn more about custody evaluations,
Click Here.
Child
Support in Wisconsin
In Wisconsin, child support is based on a
percentage of the gross (pre-tax) income of the
parent without primary physical placement. The
percentages applied are as follows: 17 percent for
one child; 25 percent for two children; 29 percent
for three children; 31 percent for four children;
and 34 percent for five or more children.
These percentages form a presumption that may be
rebutted. This means that the Court will generally
follow the guidelines unless it makes specific
findings that the guidelines should not apply
because they are overly burdensome and unfair in a
particular case.
As previously stated, there is a presumption that
each parent's time with the children should be
maximized. Often this equates to joint physical
placement. If a Court awards joint physical
placement, that is the children live about equally
with each parent, child support is usually reduced
to reflect the shared placement time. The court may
also require each parent to pay child care costs as
additional child support in proportion to the number
of days each parent has the child in his or her
care. Child care costs may encompass many thins
including food, school expenses, sports activities,
clothing and day care.
After child support has been set, it may always
be modified if there is a change in circumstance.
Since child support is based on a percentage of
gross income, it may be reduced if income decreases
or increased if income rises. This does not occur
automatically, however, and must be commenced by
filing a motion with an affidavit supporting the
modification request. If there is a change in
circumstance (increased or decreased earnings), you
must act quickly. Remember child support cannot be
forgiven except from the day that you file your
motion for a change in child support. Make sure
that you provide the Court with documents
demonstrating the increased or decreased earnings
such as paystubs, tax returns or with other
important evidence.
Child support ends at age 18 if your child is out
of high school. If your child is over 18 but still
in high school, child support can continue to age
19.
Alimony/Spousal Maintenance
Either spouse may be ordered to pay alimony,
without regard to marital fault, if it finds that
the spouse seeking maintenance: (a) lacks sufficient
property, including marital property apportioned to
the spouse, to provide for reasonable needs of the
spouse considering the standard of living
established during the marriage, especially, but not
limited to, a period of training or education, or
(b) is unable to provide adequate self-support,
after considering the standard of living established
during the marriage and all relevant circumstances,
through appropriate employment, or is the custodian
of a child whose condition or circumstances make it
appropriate that the custodian not be required to
seek employment outside the home.
If the Court determines spousal maintenance
(alimony) is appropriate, it must determine the
length of time and amount by considering all
relevant factors which may include:
- The length of the marriage.
- The age and physical and emotional health of
the parties.
- The division of marital property.
- The educational level of each party at the
time of marriage and at the time the action is
commenced.
- The earning capacity of the party seeking
maintenance, including educational background,
training, employment skills, work experience,
length of absence from the job market, custodial
responsibilities for children and the time and
expense necessary to acquire sufficient
education or training to enable the party to
find appropriate employment.
- The feasibility that the party seeking
maintenance can be-come selfsupporting at a
standard of living reasonably comparable to that
enjoyed during the marriage, and, if so, the
length of time necessary to achieve this goal.
- The tax consequences to each party.
- Any mutual agreement made by the parties
before or during the marriage, according to the
terms of which one party has made financial or
service contributions to the other with the
expectation of reciprocation or other
compensation in the future, where such repayment
has not been made, or any mutual agreement made
by the parties before or during the marriage
concerning any arrangement for the financial
support of the parties.
- The contribution by one party to the
education, training or increased earning power
of the other.
- Such other factors as the court may in each
individual case determine to be relevant.
Often in ordering spousal maintenance, Courts use
as their starting point an equalization of incomes
approach. This means that the courts will add up
the incomes of both parties and divide that figure
down the middle. Remember, this is only a starting
point and there are many variables that may result
in a deviation from this result.
Property
Divisions
Wisconsin is a marital property state. This
means that under the law there is a presumption that
any assets acquired during the marriage should be
divided equally. The valuation date for the marital
assets is the day of the final hearing unless a
different date is agreed upon by the parties, or
unless the court finds that another date of
valuation is fair and equitable.
"Nonmarital property" means property real or
personal, acquired by either spouse before, during,
or after the existence of their marriage, which (a)
is inherited by either spouse;
(b) is received as a gift by
either spouse; or (c) is paid for by funds acquired
by inheritance or gift.
Pensions, retirement plans, 401K and other
deferred compensation may all be considered marital.
The Court has the power in a divorce to appoint a
qualified person experienced in the valuation of
pension benefits and rights to function as an expert
witness in valuing pension benefits or rights.
If the parties cannot reach a comprehensive
agreement, a trial will be held on all or some of
the issues and the court will make findings of fact
and conclusions of law based upon the evidence
presented and according to applicable statutory and
case law. Once a divorce is granted, neither party
may remarry during the first six months following
the granting of the divorce, and the parties may ask
the court to vacate the divorce decree within this
initial six month period.